Best Baits You Can Use to Trap Rats

August 14, 2018 3 min read


One of the biggest frustrations in trying to trap rats is identifying the right bait for the job at hand. We often hear people say they’ve tried it all, but have had little luck in reliably attracting rodents to a trap.

Unfortunately, it’s true that finding the best bait for your particular situation might require a bit of trial and error. But the good news is that these days there are more options for rodent bait than there have ever been before, ranging from scientifically developed formulations to everyday products you probably already have in your pantry.

Here, we take a look at a few of the best bait options for trapping rats:

1. Chocolate or Nut Butter Formula Lures

One bait option that is growing in popularity is the chocolate or nut butter formula lure. The lures have been scientifically developed to attract rats for a full month, and they are designed to remain stable in all weather conditions. That means you don’t have to check or re-bait your traps as often as most other options. Plus, they’re a non-toxic option, which means they’re safe around pets and birds.

In many environments, chocolate or nut butter proves to be a great rat lure because it gives off such an attractive, distinctive aroma. Rats don’t often encounter chocolate in rural settings and around suburban lawns, so they are instinctively drawn to it when they catch a whiff.

2. Peanut Butter

Peanut butter makes an easy rat lure that most people already have in their pantry. A scoop or dollop of the spread can serve as a highly attractive bait, since it gives off an intriguing odor that rats easily detect. Another perk of peanut butter? It’s also a non-toxic option.

3. DIY Lures

In some cases, your best bet is going to be to use food that the rats have already grown accustomed to. Consider where you’re having a rodent problem. Is there dog food, animal feed, or bird seed present? Do you have a compost bin or vegetable garden, or do you regularly leave food scraps in readily accessible areas? All of these could be attracting the rats, which gives you an opportunity to create lures that you know will work.

Revolutionary, automatic, and toxin-free rat and mouse control for your home or business.

With a DIY lure basket, you have the flexibility to use whatever lure you want. So if the rats near your home have fallen in love with your pet’s food, you can incorporate it into the lure. Or, if they can’t resist your compost, add a bit to the basket. You can even supplement the lure with chocolate or nut butter formula, or peanut butter to make it even more irresistible.

4. What Not to Use

You’ll probably notice that cheese didn’t make our list, even though it’s stereotypically known as a rodent’s favorite food. For the most part, cheese isn’t very effective in the real world. That’s because some rat subspecies don’t even eat cheese, and some types of cheese simply don’t give off an appealing scent to others. With most rats, you’re better off focusing on some of the solutions above.

5. Get Creative

Remember, trapping rats takes some patience—especially in identifying what will attract them to the trap. If one bait doesn’t seem to be working after a week or so, get creative and try something else. Learn a bit about what types of rats are common in your area, and set out bait that suits their diet. In the meantime, remove other potential sources of food, such as bird feeders or pet food, so the rats will be more drawn to your bait. With a bit of patience, you’ll start to see results and know that you found the best bait for your situation.

Liquid error (social-buttons line 3): product form must be given a product

The Homeowners Guide To Catching Rats & Mice

Every year, rats and mice enter 20 million U.S. homes uninvited. They reproduce rapidly, and can cost thousands of dollars in damages and extermination costs. They can ruin equipment, spoil food and start fires by chewing on wires.

We’ve trapped millions (seriously, millions) of rats and mice and the knowledge of what it takes to achieve success is highlighted in this guide.

Homehowners Guide to Catching Rats


Also in News

Rats could be infecting you and your family already!
Rats could be infecting you and your family already!

June 20, 2022 4 min read

We’ve all heard about the health hazards associated with rats because of the diseases they can spread to humans. Who hasn’t heard of the plague?
Our Conversation With a Goodnature Customer Controlling Rats on His Property with the A24
Our Conversation With a Goodnature Customer Controlling Rats on His Property with the A24

June 16, 2022 4 min read

We recently talked with a Goodnature customer who was excited about his success with the A24 trap and wanted to share his feedback. 
home with rats
Do Rats Get Into Your Home in the Summer?

June 06, 2022 3 min read

Unless you have a pet rat, you probably don’t want one in your home. Most people are aware that rats are carriers of a number of diseases they can transfer to humans.
Home Trapping Kit | A24 Rat & Mouse Trap Kit
from $169.99
Home Trapping Kit | A24 Rat & Mouse Trap Kit w/ Counter
from $199.99
Nut Butter Pre-Feed Lure 200g